Feeds:
Posts
Comments

Posts Tagged ‘establishment’

 

Brexit_80prct

 

Robert Tombs: ’The English Revolt’: een analyse van Brexit vanuit niet-conventionele frames / in The New Statesman van 24 juli 2016

Waarom hebben de Britten voor Brexit gestemd in het referendum van 23 juni 2016? Omdat ze die kans kregen met een referendum. Zouden de Fransen, Grieken, Italianen en sommige andere EU-landen zo’n referendum voorgelegd krijgen, dan zouden ze vermoedelijk hetzelfde kiezen als de Britten: vertrek uit de EU. Natuurlijk zullen die landen van hun politici nooit een dergelijk referendum krijgen voorgelegd. Dat ligt voor de hand, omdat landen die de euro hebben ingevoerd geen duidelijke uitweg uit de EU hebben.

De ‘anti-establishment opstand’ in Groot-Brittannië die zich vertaalde in een stem voor Brexit, begon pas echt toen delen van dat establishment georganiseerde druk begonnen uit te oefenen ten gunste van een BLIJF-/REMAIN-stem. Niet alleen blijken deze personen geen idee te hebben van wat er bij de gewone man leeft, hun voornaamste argument om bij de EU te blijven was er een van puur eigenbelang: de EU is onze melkkoe en daarom moeten jullie haar blijven voeren en vetmesten. Of het nu kunstenaars waren, acteurs, filmmakers, universiteitsbestuurders of exponenten van andere prestigieuze instituten: het zijn kleine krabbelaars en wat ze lieten zien was een naargeestig verraad van kleine klerken / ‘ whether they were artists, actors, film-makers, university vice-chancellors or prestigious learned societies ….. This was a a lamentable trahison des clercs.’

 

Hieronder enkele passages uit het Engelse origineel.

‘In fact, negative opinions about the EU, and especially about its economic policy, are now more widespread in other countries than they are in England. Polls by the Pew Research Centre last month showed that disapproval of the EU was as high in Germany and the Netherlands as in Britain, and higher in France, Greece and Spain.

Why this decision? Why in Britain? The simplest and perhaps the best answer is that we have had a referendum. If France, Greece, Italy and some other countries had been given the same choice, they might well have made the same decision. But of course they have not been and will not be given such a choice, barring severe political crisis. This is most obviously because countries that have adopted the euro – even those such as Greece, for which the IMF has predicted high unemployment at least until the 2040s – have no clear way out.

As for the anti-establishment “revolt”, this emerged when parts of the establishment began to put organised pressure on the electorate to vote Remain.

Would-be opinion-formers have hardly covered themselves in glory in recent weeks. They have been out of touch and out of sympathy with opinion in the country, unwilling or unable to engage in reasoned debate, and resorting to collective proclamations of institutional authority which proved embarrassingly ineffective.

Worst of all, their main argument – whether they were artists, actors, film-makers, university vice-chancellors or prestigious learned societies – was one of unabashed self interest: the EU is our milch-cow, and hence you must feed it. This was a lamentable trahison des clercs.

The reaction to the referendum result by some Remain partisans has been a monumental fit of pique that includes talking up economic crisis (which, as Keynes showed, is often self-fulfilling) and smearing 17 million Leave voters as xenophobes. This is both irresponsible and futile, and paves the way to political marginalisation.

Many Europeans fear that a breakdown of the EU could slide into a return to the horrors of the mid-20th century. Most people in Britain do not. The fundamental feature of the referendum campaign was that the majority was not frightened out of voting for Leave, either by political or by economic warnings. This is testimony to a significant change since the last referendum in 1975: most people no longer see Britain as a declining country dependent on the EU.

A Eurobarometer poll in 2013 showed that Britain was the only EU member state in which most citizens felt that they could face the future better outside the Union. Last month’s referendum reflected this view, which was not reversed by reiterated predictions of doom. ‘

 

 

John Bull_Chris Riddell

 

EJ Bron Brexit

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Read Full Post »